Consumer class actions seeking a share of IEEPA tariff refunds, first reported here on March 10 and April 27, now number more than 100 putative class actions pending in federal district courts against importers and retailers that paid IEEPA duties and are recovering them from U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The litigation has continued as CAPE refunds have reached importers of record, the development addressed in our September 4 report, Private Disputes Over IEEPA Tariff Refunds Emerge as CAPE Payments Reach Importers of Record. No court has yet ruled on whether a company must share an IEEPA refund with its customers. The lead motion to dismiss, in Stockov v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. 1:26-cv-02734 (N.D. Ill.), remains pending.

The named defendants range from national retailers to consumer brands and carriers. Walmart faces at least seven federal suits, filed in the Western District of Arkansas on April 22, the Northern District of Ohio on April 27, the Southern District of Florida on May 22, the Middle District of Florida on September 10, the District of New Jersey on September 28, the District of Connecticut on September 30 and the Northern District of Texas on October 2. Costco reported four suits, all filed in March, in its quarterly report for the period ended May 10, 2026. Other defendants include Amazon, Target, Nike, Nintendo, Logitech, Puma, Abercrombie & Fitch and Peloton, as well as carriers such as FedEx and UPS that billed customers directly for duties.

The complaints generally plead unjust enrichment and violations of state consumer protection statutes. They allege that the defendants raised prices to offset IEEPA duties and will recover the same cost twice, once from customers and again from CBP. Many rely on executives’ public statements that prices were raised because of tariffs. The relief sought typically includes restitution and a constructive trust or equitable lien on refund proceeds.

Costco moved to dismiss Stockov on May 18, arguing that the claims were not ripe because no refunds had issued, and that the plaintiff received the goods he paid for at the prices stated. In an August 12 filing, the plaintiff argued that the ripeness argument had fallen away because Costco had begun receiving refunds while the motion was pending. Nintendo moved on July 20 to dismiss Hoffert v. Nintendo of America Inc., No. 2:26-cv-01360 (W.D. Wash.), arguing that purchasers have no legal entitlement to the refunds. In the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Five Below moved on July 29 to dismiss a consumer suit; that case was consolidated with a second suit on October 2, and the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on November 2. No decision on any of these motions has been reported. The first reported ruling in this group of cases did not reach the merits: on November 2, Judge James L. Robart of the Western District of Washington held in Hastings v. Microsoft Corp. that the warranty and agreement packaged with an Xbox Series X requires individual arbitration of the plaintiff’s claims and bars him from suing on behalf of a class.

On October 2, the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation centralized the consumer suits against Amazon in the Western District of Washington as In re Amazon Tariff Litigation, MDL No. 3197. A separate motion to combine suits against many different retailers in a single cross-industry proceeding, In re Retailer Tariff Litigation, remains pending before the Panel. Thirteen defendants, including Walmart, Costco and Amazon, filed a joint opposition on September 10, arguing that the cases share no common pricing decision, supplier or course of conduct.

No court has certified a consumer class in any of these cases. The only class certified to date in the IEEPA refund litigation is the importer class certified on October 8 by Court of International Trade Judge Richard K. Eaton in Freestyle World, Inc. v. United States, covering importers whose finally liquidated entries were excluded from CAPE. Under the refund process, only the importer of record may claim a refund from CBP. The consumer suits do not challenge that rule; they seek to reach the refund after it is paid, and their exposure grows as CAPE Phase 3 releases refunds on finally liquidated entries.

Posted
AuthorMatt Nakachi